10 Best Store Bought Pizza Sauce 2023 – Elevate Your Homemade Pizza Game

Store Bought Pizza Sauce

As someone who’s always on the hunt for the perfect pizza night, I’ve come to realize that while a good crust is essential, the magic truly lies in the sauce.

Over the years, I’ve tossed and turned pizzas in my kitchen, experimenting with homemade sauces and those straight off the store shelves. And let’s be honest, sometimes we just don’t have the time to simmer a sauce from scratch.

That’s when a reliable store-bought pizza sauce becomes a lifesaver. I’ve journeyed through aisles, and tasted countless brands, and today, I’m eager to share my discoveries with fellow pizza lovers.

What is the Best Store Bought Pizza Sauce?

There are various brands, and flavors of store-bought pizza sauces. Choosing the best store bought pizza can be overwhelming. After gathering all information and doing extensive research, we have come up with our top five choices for the best store bought  products.

1. Don Pepino 

Don Pepino Pizza Sauce

Check on Amazon

Check on Walmart

The original household formula of Don Pepino was fondly used in various homemade cooking since 1950. Tomatoes, selected at their maximum ripeness and added to the filling in a specific production method that locks the most exquisite taste and aroma in the packaged wrapped product, are at the core of this unique recipe.

The tomatoes that are used to create it are new and are capable of released into since they can achieve their complete ripeness in the vine instead of containers for storage.

The fresh, whole tomatoes are blended into cholesterol-free maize oil, and the herbs and spices are specialized to make it soft and delectable, so popular among children and adults, as children don’t want sauces which are too strong and tangy.

The sauce is safe from components, which are of concern to many of us when purchasing prepared seasonings like citric acid, synthetic colors, spice, and chemical preservatives.

There are 12 pizza-sauce containers each of 15 ounces, so if you’re searching for a household set of pie sauces to stay in the cupboard and use for a considerable period, this is likely an excellent option for you.

  • An original family recipe
  • Only ripe tomatoes included
  • Cholesterol-free corn oil
  • No harmful chemicals
  • Spices that produce flavorful taste
  • May contain seeds
  • Distinct taste requires getting used to


2. Muir Glen Organic 

Muir Glen Organic Pizza Sauce

Check on Amazon

Check on Walmart

Check on eBay

If it is a pizza sauce made from freshly harvested tomatoes that you would like to have to be as close together as necessary, Muir Glen might be just the one for you. You no longer have to spend hours preparing the pizza sauce in the kitchen.  

Because organic fertilizer is cultivated in organic farms, there is no danger of adverse effects on health, and the sauce flavor is very similar to the new tomato-made sauce.

This sauce may bring pleasure to herbal enthusiasts because it includes black pepper, basil, and oregano.

Another excellent tip to healthy individuals is that it is possible to consume and enjoy the BPA-free lining safely for an extended period.

In addition to its pure excellence, the business that produces it has other highlights, for instance, earned a conservation prize for the composting procedures which have turned waste generated from the farms into soil rich in nutrients.

It also has continuing habitat creation programs for pollinators like bees together with the tomato plants, which assist in maintaining and protecting the natural ecosystem.

  • Organically cultivated tomatoe
  • Rich aroma and flavor
  • No BPA products included
  • No additional sugar
  • Poor packaging compared to other brands


3. Pastorelli Italian Chef

Pastorelli Pizza Sauce Italian Chef

Check on Amazon

Check on Kiky

Check on Pastorelli

Pizza is probably Italy’s most important meal. While this delightful food came from Italy, it is nowadays consumed worldwide. It is an excellent beginning if you want a real touch of Italian in your baked pizza. Pastorelli is one of Central Italy’s companies with long, exciting origins.

In the 1800s, one member of the Pastorelli household started to distribute meals in Italy. His son carried the heritage of the family to the United States subsequently. In 1952, Pastorelli’s first canned product, which gave a genuine flavor and aroma of Italian gastronomy, was launched to the industry.

The flavor of the original one remained relevant to this recipe even today. The sauce comes from the best tomatoes in the San Marzano style that have a sweet taste and acidity. It includes Pecorino Romano cheese as an additive, which adds more flavor to the sauce.


Pecorino Romano is an excellent seasoning for the soup, pizza, pasta, or salad, and renowned for its brilliant, sharp and salty flavors.

The mixture of extra virgin olive oil, onions, salt, garlic, tomatoes, and Pecorino Romano cheese gives this one an authentic taste of Italian pizza, which you can enjoy at your convenience.

  • The company has its origin in Italy
  • Includes a Pecorino Romano cheese
  • Includes garlic, salt, and extra virgin olive oil
  • BPA-free and safe to use.
  • Can be used on other foods
  • Pecorino Romano’s taste is not for everyone


4. Chef Boyardee Sauce with Cheese

Chef Boyardee Pizza Sauce with Cheese

Check on Amazon

Check on DvaSata


The two secrets as to what makes up Chef Boyardee as good at it is are the strong tastes of vine-ripe tomatoes and creamy mouth-watering cheddar cheese. It is not only the ideal foundation for your favorite pizza topping, but it could likewise be an effective way of making delightful meals, from toasted bread to pancakes.

Since it has Italian spices and is made more efficient by cheddar, you don’t have to spice the cheese up by introducing additional cheese or distinct components to pastry sauces of a mild flavor.


Perhaps you would like a cheaper brand that is more widely recognized. This sauce might be ideal for you if that is the situation. The label in the can explains all the components included. In every serving, you likewise have data about the calories.

There are no preservatives that alter the taste, and you shouldn’t have to care about anything regarding destroying the rich flavors.

  • It includes cheddar cheese
  • Can be used on other foods
  • Italian herbs 
  • The quantity of calories.
  • 8 ounces
  • The meat is not so flavorful


5. Godfather’s 

Godfather's Pizza Sauce

Check on Amazon Check on Walmart


This sauce is an excellent option for everyone who wants a pizza sauce in a glass bottle rather than a can. Many of us are reluctant to use canned meat because of health impacts and prefer meat stored in glass containers.

The range of tomatoes it utilizes is another unique characteristic of this pizza sauce.

The Italian heirloom, Godfather’s has a range of feather tomatoes that are regarded as the best tomatoes for Italian dishes because of their sweet flavor, minimal acidity, and crunchy texture.

  • American variant of tomato that has low acidity
  • It is stored in a glass jar
  • 14 ounces of filling.
  • The flavor is not for everyone


6. Stanislaus 

Stanislaus Pizza Sauce

Check on Amazon

Check on PlanetsHoup


My friend recently introduced me to the Stanislaus, and I was genuinely impressed by their enthusiasm for it. They raved about how this sauce has been crafted by a company that’s been in the business for over 80 years.

What stood out the most was the authentic taste, made from California-grown tomatoes. They mentioned the inclusion of virgin olive oil, sunflower oil, and a mix of spices like basil, oregano, and garlic, which gave the sauce a fresh and vibrant flavor.


The slightly chunky texture was just right, adding a nice depth to every bite of the pizza. They also appreciated the generous size of the can, which weighed almost 7 pounds, ensuring many delightful pizza nights ahead.

After opening, they found it super convenient to store what’s left in a mason jar, keeping it fresh for the next use. While it’s a bit on the pricier side compared to other sauces, the quality and quantity make it worth every penny.

  • California-grown tomatoes
  • Includes virgin olive oil and fresh herbs
  • Authentic, fresh-tasting ingredient
  • Suitable for homemade pizzas
  • Easy storage after opening
  • Large packaging


Store Bought vs Homemade

Store Bought Pizza Sauce

The heart and soul of your enterprise are your menu options, and you are likely to be working conscientiously with your supplier to select the types of crust that are best suited to your recipe and enhance kitchen productivity. It is an excellent business strategy with which you can equally apply to sauces.

Nevertheless, one pressing question is: “Which type can save you more time and money for your business? Is it homemade pizza sauces or store-bought pizza sauces?”


Pizza manufacturers bring pleasure in their products and often work with the whole family over generations to improve the pizza-specific flavor. Homemade variants are either cooked or uncooked. As to which one you will choose depends on personal preference and habits.

But what is the difference between the two?

The cooked is most often stewed for several hours to create intense and profound flavors and is recognized by patrons through the distinctive brownish-orange color. The method has the added implications of penetrating the process with an odor that genuinely fills your craving.

Still, the supporters of the fresh ones claim that cooked may smell burned.

The uncooked soup has a fresh flavor of tomatoes. High seasonal, “fresh packed” tomato items can be used by producers to get light red, sweet that doesn’t require cooking before use. The process only involves canning with low heat.

“Fresh package” is essential- the use of re-manufactured tomato products would not produce fresh outcomes as tomato paste will be diluted back after the end of the tomato season.

For fresh variant advocates, they consider it as authentic and flavorful. For cooked advocates, they think the fresh variant is too sour and moist for crusts.

Store Bought 

Whether it is fresh or cooked, homemade pizza sauces take time, and this can be very challenging for kitchens that are always packed with orders to complete.

Some providers choose to use ready-made tomato bases and incorporate spice mixtures. This spares time; however, consistency is almost always disputed. Does every package use the same quantity of spice? Is it as thick as the tomato base? Is each sample blended correctly to even dispersion of spices and flavor?

All of these issues are relevant, and your supplier probably has an alternative. Store bought pizza sauces are excellent choices: new or cooked sauce, produced from genuine Italian ingredients and stored at a freshness level of the same top quality ingredients you like to use.

Variety also doesn’t have any problems with store-bought ones because these sauces are often available from manufacturers. Some companies will even operate with you to produce unique sauces for your pizzas and pasta –a mark that contains the flavors that your customers love and can prepare in a split moment!

Is It the Same as Pasta Sauce?

Fully ready one, with all its benefits, is perfect for double flavor in pizzas and pasta. Pasta sauce, however, varies in many respects. It has more water and less pulp compared to pizza sauce.

In addition to uncooked tomato pizza sauce, pasta sauce is improved with flavored seasonings such as onions, herbs, and garlic. Typically, it is highly fat with olive oil that is dense and pulpy. It is usually less fat and thicker and gives a smoother sensation in the throat.

This does not imply that your kitchen must get stuck with the preparation of distinct pasta sauces. Many products from the manufacturers also supply ready-made pasta sauces and pizza sauces.

The preparation of sauce made from scratch or completely ready carry a big bunch of aroma, but the only store-bought sauce can simplify your inventory, save time, and reduce expenses without affecting performance or consistency.

Different Types 

When it comes to pizzas, whether it be in toppings or crust, everybody has varied preferences. However, not too many people consider the pizza sauce that is used to perfectly blend to the pizza’s ingredients, giving a delicious flavor combination. You can always use the pizza sauce for dipping meat or vegetables.

Also, there is significant variety from package to package about the amount of spice, thickness, and how each product is stored for longevity. Consider reading the pizza sauce label because custom packaging vendors like this frequently include information on how to best prepare the meal and enjoy the full flavor as intended.

Here are some of the commonest ones:.


In sweet pizza sauce, the sweetness is obtained from the tomatoes and other added sugar. Sweet sauces of tomatoes work well with pineapple, vegetables, sweet foods, including sausages and bacon.

The sauce does not work well with more flavorful aromas, as the sweet and tangy aromas compete too differently to be a satisfying combination.


You might think of salsa when you hear the word “spicy.” The spicy pizza sauce is a mixture of spices, vinegar, hot sauce, and butter. The spicy sauce requires flavorful food for balancing. Hence, some of the perfect choices are pepperoni and beef.

Bacon, mushrooms, and sausages are also excellent toppings for sweet pizza. To add more spice, include red pepper flakes!


Pesto Pizza

If you are a pesto lover, you can also have pesto sauce on your next pizza. Pesto pizza sauce has ingredients such as roasted pine nuts, Parmesan cheese, olive oil, basil, and garlic. If you are tired of having cheese pizza all the time, pesto pizza sauce is likely what you need as an alternative.

With pesto pizza, you may add tomatoes and chicken as toppings.


In various Italian pizza recipes, basil is an essential ingredient. Hence, incorporating basil on your pizza sauce can provide that “classical Italian” taste. Some vegetables or mushrooms would be a favorable addition that combines well with the bright aroma of tomato and basil.


Alfredo as a pizza sauce gives you the buttery and creamy flavor combined with spices and loads of cheeses. It is very well combined with ingredients which have a strong aroma, such as olives, processed meat, steak, mushrooms, bacon, roasted peppers, and artichoke hearts.


BBQ Chicken Pizza

BBQ is often associated with ribs and meat. Surprisingly, you can also have BBQ pizza sauce and top it with your favorite ingredients. With BBQ sauce, you can have toppings such as pineapple for a sweet flavor, bacon, chicken, and ham.


A pepper pizza sauce is one that uses all kinds of peppers. Red pepper, black pepper, roasted red pepper, and cayenne pepper are some of the typical ingredients. Just like spicy ones, you can have different toppings on your dish. Some examples of toppings you may incorporate are mushrooms, steak, and chicken.


FAQ - pizza sauce

Can you freeze store-bought pizza sauce? 

Yes, you can freeze store-bought pizza sauce. Freezing the sauce can help extend its shelf life and make it more convenient to use in the future

How long does store-bought pizza sauce last after opening?

Once opened, store-bought pizza sauce should be refrigerated and typically lasts 5-7 days. Always check the label for specific storage instructions.

Are there store-bought pizza sauces without added sugar?

Yes, many brands offer pizza sauces without added sugars. It’s essential to read the ingredient list to ensure no sugars or sweeteners are added.

Can I enhance the flavor of a store-bought pizza sauce?

Absolutely! You can add fresh herbs, spices, garlic, or even a splash of olive oil to enhance the flavor according to your preference.

Is there a difference in flavor between canned and jarred pizza sauces?

The packaging might not significantly affect the flavor, but the ingredients and the brand’s recipe will. Both canned and jarred options can offer delicious flavors.

Can you use store-bought alfredo sauce instead of pizza sauce?

While store-bought alfredo sauce can be used as a pizza sauce substitute, it may not provide the same flavor profile as traditional pizza sauce. 

If you do decide to use alfredo as an alternative, it’s important to keep in mind that the texture and consistency may be different than traditional pones. Alfredo is typically thicker and creamier, so you may need to spread it on the pizza crust more carefully to avoid making it too heavy.

Final Thoughts

After a flavorful expedition through jars and bottles of pizza sauces, it’s clear that the market offers a delightful array of choices for every palate. From tangy and robust to sweet and herby, the right sauce can truly transform your pizza experience.

While making sauce from scratch has its charm, there’s undeniable convenience in grabbing a trusted store-bought brand. Here’s to many more pizza nights filled with the perfect balance of crust, toppings, and of course, the star – the sauce!

Related post: The Best Pizza Cutter for a Quick Yummy Treat!

Picture of Mary J. Lynch

Mary J. Lynch

As a mom of two angels, I credit myself in making meals with high concentration yet the balance of nutrition. I pay good care about the health of my family and everyone. Thus, you will find most of my recipes focus on healthy ingredients.
Related Posts